Field Sobriety Test Defense

Failed a Field Sobriety Test?
That Does Not Mean You Were Impaired

Field sobriety tests are the eye test, the walk and turn and the one leg stand that officers ask drivers to perform on the side of the road. They are voluntary in Florida, they are scored by the same officer who is deciding whether to arrest you, and nerves, footwear, uneven pavement and medical conditions can all make a sober person look impaired. Our team pairs a former Seminole County prosecutor with a former Ninth Circuit assistant public defender, so we know how roadside evidence is built and where it breaks down. Free, confidential consultations are available 24/7.

Arrested after roadside tests?

The video and the officer’s notes may tell a different story.

Act quickly

Why the Roadside Tests Matter So Much

Field sobriety tests are how officers build probable cause to arrest you and ask for a breath, urine or blood test. If the tests were given or scored the wrong way, everything that came after them can be challenged.

3

Standardized tests set by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)

0

License suspensions for politely declining the roadside exercises

10 days

To challenge the administrative suspension after a DUI arrest

A DUI arrest after roadside testing can be fought on two fronts:

1

Challenge the administrative suspension

You have 10 days from the arrest to request a formal review hearing, where the officer’s reasons for the arrest, including the roadside tests, can be questioned.

2

Challenge the criminal case

If the tests do not support probable cause, the arrest and the breath or blood results that followed it may be suppressed.

Roadside videos fade from storage and memories of the scene fade too. Call us as soon as you can. We will request the footage, compare it to the police report, and look for every mistake in how the tests were given and scored.

YOUR DEFENSE TEAM

DUI Defense From Both Sides of the Courtroom

Every DUI case we take gets two perspectives: a lawyer who used to decide which DUI cases to file and what to offer, and a lawyer who has defended thousands of people in Central Florida courtrooms.

David A. Webster

Former State Prosecutor

David prosecuted cases for the 18th Judicial Circuit, which covers Seminole and Brevard Counties. He knows what a DUI file looks like from the prosecutor’s desk, which weaknesses lead to reduced charges, and which cases are worth taking to a jury.

Samantha Lambert

Former assistant public defender

Samantha handled thousands of cases as an assistant public defender for the Ninth Judicial Circuit, which covers Orange and Osceola Counties. She knows the Orlando and Kissimmee courtrooms, judges and procedures that most DUI cases in those counties pass through.

Arrested after field sobriety tests? Talk to us today.

Free, confidential consultations, available 24/7.

Avvo 9.4 "Superb"
Super Lawyers
Top 100 Trial Lawyer

STATE V. TAYLOR

You Can Say No to the Roadside Tests

Florida law does not require you to perform field sobriety exercises, and declining them does not suspend your license. The Florida Supreme Court has ruled that prosecutors may still tell a jury you refused, but you are free to explain why, and a refusal on its own is not proof of impairment. A breath, urine or blood test after a lawful arrest is different: refusing one carries a license suspension and, since October 2025, a criminal charge.

ROADSIDE EXERCISES

Voluntary

No license suspension for declining

BREATH, URINE OR BLOOD

Implied consent

A 1 year suspension and a misdemeanor for a first refusal

WHAT WE HANDLE

Field Sobriety Test Problems We Challenge

Horizontal gaze nystagmus

Eye jerking has many causes besides alcohol, and Florida courts limit how officers can describe the results.

Declining the tests

Refusing the roadside exercises is your right, and we make sure the jury hears why you said no.

Walk and turn

Nine heel to toe steps on a line, scored for 8 clues, on whatever ground the officer picked.

One leg stand

Thirty seconds on one foot is hard for many sober people, especially in shoes, wind or traffic.

Instructions given wrong

The tests are only valid when the officer follows NHTSA’s instructions and scoring rules exactly.

Bad testing conditions

Sloped or uneven pavement, poor lighting, flashing lights and passing cars all affect performance.

Medical and physical conditions

Age, weight, injuries, inner ear problems and certain medications can cause clues in sober people.

Breath and blood tests

A weak roadside investigation can undermine the arrest and the chemical test that followed it.

Nonstandard tests

The alphabet, finger to nose and counting tests were never validated by NHTSA research.

Drug impairment claims

The standardized tests were designed and validated for alcohol, not for marijuana or prescription drugs.

NHTSA STANDARDIZED FIELD SOBRIETY TESTS

How Officers Score the Three Tests

In NHTSA’s original 1981 laboratory research, each test alone correctly flagged a blood alcohol level of 0.10 or higher only 65 to 77 percent of the time. Later studies reported higher numbers at 0.08, but only when officers gave and scored the tests exactly as trained.

Even then, the tests estimate the likelihood of a certain blood alcohol level. They do not measure whether you could drive safely, and any shortcut by the officer weakens the result.

Test What the Officer Scores 1981 NHTSA Accuracy
Horizontal gaze nystagmus 6 clues, 3 per eye. 4 or more counts as a fail. 77 percent
Walk and turn 8 clues, such as stepping off the line or using arms for balance. 2 or more counts as a fail. 68 percent
One leg stand 4 clues: swaying, using arms, hopping or putting the foot down. 2 or more counts as a fail. 65 percent
Eye test and walk and turn together Combined results of both tests 80 percent
OUR APPROACH

How We Defend DUI Cases

As a former prosecutor, David learned which DUI cases fall apart under scrutiny. We look for the same weak points in every case we take.

The stop

Police need a lawful reason to pull you over. If they did not have one, the evidence that followed may be thrown out.

The roadside investigation

Field sobriety exercises are subjective and often done wrong, on uneven ground or in bad lighting.

The breath test

Machines must be maintained and operators must follow strict rules, including a 20 minute observation period.

Blood and urine evidence

We check how samples were drawn, stored and tested, and whether the chain of custody holds up.

The video

Body camera, dash camera and booking footage often contradict the police report.

Medical and timing issues

Acid reflux, diabetes, certain diets and rising blood alcohol can produce misleading numbers.

Depending on what we find, the goal is a dismissal, a reduction to a lesser charge such as reckless driving, a diversion option where the county offers one, or a not guilty verdict at trial.

THE PROCESS

What Happens After a DUI Arrest in Central Florida

1. Arrest and booking

Held at least 8 hours, or until your BAC is under 0.05 or you are no longer impaired.

2. First appearance

A judge sets release conditions, usually within 24 hours.

3. 10 day license decision

Request a formal review hearing or waive it for an eligibility review.

4. Arraignment

We can usually file a written not guilty plea for you.

5. Discovery

Reports, video, breath machine records and lab results.

6. Motions and negotiation

We challenge illegal evidence and use what we find.

7. Resolution or trial

Dismissal, a reduced charge, a plea or a jury trial.

AREAS WE SERVE

Where We Defend DUI Cases

From our Longwood office, we defend DUI charges in county and circuit courts across six Central Florida counties.

Orange County

9th circuit

Orange County Courthouse · 425 N. Orange Ave., Orlando

Orlando, Winter Park, Apopka, Winter Garden, Ocoee and Maitland. Where Samantha Lambert spent years as an assistant public defender.

Seminole County

18th circuit

Criminal Justice Center · 101 Eslinger Way, Sanford

Sanford, Lake Mary, Oviedo, Altamonte Springs, Casselberry, Winter Springs and Longwood. Where David Webster served as a prosecutor.

Osceola County

9th circuit

Osceola County Courthouse · 2 Courthouse Square, Kissimmee

Kissimmee, St. Cloud, Celebration and Poinciana.

Brevard County

18TH CIRCUIT

Moore Justice Center · 2825 Judge Fran Jamieson Way, Viera

Melbourne, Palm Bay, Titusville, Cocoa and Cocoa Beach.

Volusia County

7TH CIRCUIT

Volusia County Courthouse · 101 N. Alabama Ave., DeLand

Daytona Beach, DeLand, Deltona, Ormond Beach and New Smyrna Beach.

Lake County

5TH CIRCUIT

Lake County Judicial Center · 550 W. Main St., Tavares

Clermont, Leesburg, Eustis, Mount Dora and Tavares.

CLIENT REVIEWS

What Our DUI Clients Say

Real reviews from clients we have represented across Central Florida, verified on our Google Business Profile.

Google
Bill profile picture
Bill
119 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
A Big thank you on a job well done to David Webster , Samantha and my fav front desk lady at the Webster law firm . In this World Cup soccer time I can only describe them as “ the Dream team “ , led by Lionel Messi . They Represented me in a very tricky DUI case which should have been thrown out as a bad stop at the first hearing but was forwarded to a jury trial due to a change of judge at the last minute . I was very nervous about the whole jury trial process , but David put me at ease and guided me through jury selection and a 4 hour trial that Ultimately resulted in a not guilty verdict . Davids command of the courtroom and the legal process is top notch . His years in the legal field are very evident and will result in a favorable outcome to your case . His Rebuttal of the prosecution case and evidence, Sheer determination and extended effort to have your side of the story heard , will lead you to be in no doubt that you have hired the Right lawyer and law firm . I would have no hesitation in Recommending the Webster law firm in Longwood Florida . Many Thanks from a Relieved Florida Driver .
Google
Nathan profile picture
Nathan
179 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I have wanted to write this review for so long and now that my case is settled… I finally feel like I can do it. The TLDR version… they’re the best in the area and it’s not even close. If you need an attorney and can hire them - do it. Ask for Samantha Lambert and trust her. It is the best decision you will ever make and these are generally not times to roll the dice. I’d always heard great things about David Webster. To be fair, he is probably one of the most desired attorneys in the area. I have no doubt he’s great, but this isn’t the whole story. There is another attorney working out of Mr. Webster’s office that’s just unbelievably talented. Her name is Samantha Lambert. Samantha is likely the most effective attorney I’ve ever worked with or spoken to. Unfortunately, I’ve had to hire a lot of different attorneys over the years… and no one comes even close. She’s in another league. She’s brilliant, patient, detailed, and most importantly… she is prepared. She thinks ahead in the way only someone who has prepared can do. My case was weird; messy. It was over 15-years old, but it was a serious case. Everything was stacked against me and she carefully navigated it all like a professional. She got me a bond in the most unlikely bond scenario; then she got to work on my case (she won) and today I am free. Try to trust me when I tell you that she is very likely the best criminal defense attorney you’re going to meet. It’s an absolute pleasure talking with her, too. She is empathetic in a way that’s not ridiculous: she’s not going to beat around the bush or dote on you… but she is going to actually hear what you’re saying. She is going to remember it; she’s going to figure it into the case or how she handles the case. To be totally frank, I couldn’t put into words how I feel about her if I was paid to. She is just an amazing woman; an awesome person and an absolute rock star attorney. I could spend days going on and on about her. You are lucky if she is able to take the case. It’s that simple. Trust her. Give her room. Let her work. You’re in good hands.
Google
Santiago Trentini (Santi) profile picture
Santiago Trentini (Santi)
302 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
They are very knowledgeable, kind, reassuring and answer messages very quickly. They are amazing at what they do and a perfect option for Seminole county. Don’t go to court without a lawyer!
Google
Kristen profile picture
Kristen
370 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Grateful for Attorney Dave Webster Dave Webster is an amazing attorney who truly cares about the people he helps. He represented my mom from start to finish and won her case, showing dedication and compassion every step of the way. I also consulted with Dave after a situation where I was injured as the victim, and his guidance helped me receive the assistance I needed. I’m beyond grateful for his knowledge, kindness, and support. I highly recommend Dave Webster to anyone in need of an attorney who goes above and beyond for his clients.
Google
Robin Dailey profile picture
Robin Dailey
371 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I cannot recommend David Webster highly enough—he is simply the best! From the moment he took on my case, I felt completely taken care of. David was so wonderful; he answered every single call and question I had, no matter how small or repetitive. Navigating a legal matter can be stressful, but David's professionalism and constant reassurance throughout the entire process made all the difference. He is knowledgeable, incredibly responsive, and truly cares about his clients. If you need someone who will be in your corner every step of the way, David Webster is your man. If I could give 10 stars, I would! Thank you for everything!
Google
DougSpence profile picture
DougSpence
421 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Samantha Lambert was by my side from the first hearing until the complete dismissal. Samantha was very communicative and helpful. I’ve never been involved in something like this and having this firm represent me allowed me to calmly digest every step without the fear of the unknown. Thank you Samantha for the confidence you displayed and the followthrough that you demonstrated. I appreciate your hard work.
Google
Robert Lee profile picture
Robert Lee
561 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
7/5 stars, truly. When him and his team take a case, they get work done. Efficient, honest, and absolutely effective.
Google
cleat simmons profile picture
cleat simmons
561 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The defense team of David Webster and Samantha Lambert are a formidable ally when you need legal representation in a criminal defense matter. David was recommended to me many years ago and he has been a tremendous resource. He is friendly, treats you like he genuinely cares (which he obviously does), and exudes confidence based on his many years of experience. Samantha is just as friendly and confident. Recently Samantha handled a hearing on a serious matter for a family member with unmatched expertise and achieved the right result. Their knowledge of the law, the court system, and the prosecutorial process is unmatched. If you want excellent representation you should hire the firm that has expertise based on having been where the opposition is. They are inside the head of the prosecutors, know how they think, what their strategies are, and how to beat them at their game. You can do no better than having David Webster and Samantha Lambert at your side.
Google
Brandon Dark profile picture
Brandon Dark
562 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Dave is the GOAT. His office, representation, staff and associate attorney, Samantha, are second to none. If you, a family member, or friend need the best, call Dave Webster. 10 stars.
Google
Hayden Miller profile picture
Hayden Miller
589 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
For the past several years, I have relied on the Webster law firm to provide me with expert legal representation, and they have never failed to deliver. From juvenile cases to adult cases, and from misdemeanors to felonies, they have consistently demonstrated a deep understanding of the law and a commitment to achieving the best possible outcomes. I am particularly grateful to Samantha, who has handled the majority of my cases with professionalism, expertise, and a genuine concern for my well-being. Thank you, Samantha, and thank you, Dave, for your hard work and dedication to your clients.

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case is different and must be judged on its own facts.

FAQ

Field Sobriety Test Questions We Hear Every Day

Do I have to take field sobriety tests in Florida?

No. The roadside exercises are voluntary, and declining them does not suspend your license. Only a refusal of a breath, urine or blood test after a lawful arrest carries a suspension.

Can refusing field sobriety tests be used against me?

Yes. The Florida Supreme Court allows prosecutors to mention the refusal at trial, but you can explain your reasons, and a refusal alone does not prove impairment.

How accurate are field sobriety tests?

In NHTSA’s original research, each test was accurate 65 to 77 percent of the time. Later studies reported higher numbers, but only when the tests were given and scored exactly by the book.

Can the eye test be used against me in court?

Only in a limited way. Florida courts treat horizontal gaze nystagmus as scientific evidence, so the state must lay a proper foundation before the results come in, and an officer’s casual opinion is not enough.

What if I have a medical condition or injury?

Back, leg and inner ear problems, age, weight, fatigue and some medications can all cause clues. NHTSA’s own training materials recognize that some people cannot fairly perform these tests.

Can I be arrested even if I passed the tests?

Yes. Officers can rely on other observations, such as driving pattern, odor or speech. A good performance on video becomes strong evidence for your defense.

Are the roadside tests recorded?

Often. Body cameras and dash cameras usually capture the tests, and the footage frequently contradicts the officer’s written report. We request it right away.

Do field sobriety tests detect drug impairment?

They were designed and validated for alcohol. For drug cases, officers may call in a drug recognition expert, whose evaluation can be challenged in its own right.